As someone who is both a libertarian and a Republican I have a somewhat complicated relationship with conservatism and what some self-identified conservatives claim it means to be conservative.
Chiefly the trouble lies in the fact that most every conservative claims they are supporters of individual liberty and limited government, but then toss away those concerns the moment it involves liberty for someone they don’t approve of, whether they be gays, immigrants, Muslims, or other unpopular minorities.
Mostly I’ve focused on immigration and how many on the right so easily reject the free market in order to subsidize American labor interests. This time though, I want to focus on another aspect of so-called conservatives enabling statism.
In a recent post Ann Corcoran of Potomac Tea Party Report responds to a report highlighting incidences of police brutality by cavalierly dismissing it as so much political agitprop from the Left.
This is unconscionable if you honestly believe in limited government. I care about things like the tax code and land use policy, and I certainly recognize how the state uses them to restrict individual liberty. But the police being free to brutalize innocent people and even to egregiously violate the civil rights of actual criminals is a massively bigger threat to individual liberty.
And contrary to Corcoran’s implication, this isn’t something that was made up by the Obama administration or George Soros or some other bogeyman leftist.
I spent about 5 minutes on investigative journalist and libertarian activist Radley Balko’s site and found the following:
- Over 380 cases of police breaking into people’s homes and terrorizing the occupants while doing no-knock drug raids. These incidents frequently feature physical harm being inflicted on occupants and put both young children and elderly relatives at risk. In virtually every case they either found only miniscule amounts of marijuana or actually had hit the wrong house.
- Over 320 cases of police shooting people’s dogs when the dogs posed no threat to the officers. In many cases people pleaded with the officers to allow them to pen the dogs or otherwise restrain them but the officers refused to do so and shot the dogs instead.
- Something like 700 cases of police getting away with flagrant violations of the law either because other police officers refused to enforce the law against them or courts refused to consider as valid testimony that contradicted the claims of the offending officers.
Spend a bit of time reading through the linked material. It’s horrifying to think that this sort of thing happens in America today. We’re a far sight better than places like North Korea, China, or the various authoritarian tyrannies of Africa and the Middle East, but the state is still egregiously violating individual liberty in the United States and in ways a whole lot worse than excessive marginal tax rates.
Just because those abuses aren’t terribly visible to people like Corcoran or myself it doesn’t mean they aren’t real and it certainly doesn’t mean that they aren’t an issue that limited government advocates ought to be outraged about.
Follow on Twitter
Add on Facebook
E-mail Me

Recent Comments